I'm finding myself confused by apparent inherent contradictions in world view behind some religious ideas I see on Facebook. Coming at this from an anthropological perspective, I ought to try to involve myself in that culture to learn how people who are part of religious community that believes in things like efficacy of prayer perceive their world. Maybe I could even do it. I'm reminded of an example in one of my textbooks about a woman who was doing fieldwork in a Wiccan coven. She realized that she'd mistakenly left her wristwatch on while they were involved in a ritual. Since the group's understanding was that wearing electronics while involved in a ritual would cause them to malfunction due to the energies involved, the anthropologist's first instinctive thought when she noticed her watch wasn't working was that it had failed because she'd left it on during the ceremony. So maybe I really could get involved enough in a Christian group to assume, at least for a little bit, their world view on this.
But it's hard. There are aspects of some varieties of religious thought that I just don't understand.
Please pray immediately for a young lady who is fighting for her life right now - [NAME REMOVED BY ME]. She is fighting a heart problem she's had for years. In the last 3 days it has elevated to the point that her body could give out at any moment. They've already had to shock her back to life 3 times, but don't know what else to do for her. She has a strong faith and love for Jesus Christ and is ready for whatever He has in store for her. The doctors are baffled right now but God isn't. Please pray His will for her life.
This is a sad thing for those involved. But why would God tease people this way by sickening someone and then making zir healthy again in response to prayer. That's awfully capricious. Does he want to make sure that zir loved ones care enough about zir to pray? How does one reconcile these things that seem irreconcilable to me?
At least one person offered to pray for my dad while he was in the hospital, and I appreciated the thought. While I may not believe that the action will have any direct effect, I can still pass on the fact that the prayer is concerned. It's nice to know that people care about you when you're sick, and I appreciate the expression of care and concern that it is. Good will is always worth while and worth sharing, and I won't be critical of that because it comes in a form I wouldn't offer myself. But as for some kind of direct affect of prayer on anything outside of in a social context, I don't believe it.
If God is all powerful, then whatever he wants will happen, so why bother praying? If he's not all powerful or doesn't exist, then why bother praying at all? I guess the answer is partly that not everything in life is, or should be, approached from a purely rational perspective.
Maybe this sort of request is primarily a form taken by the social ritual of a group of connected people expressing concern and solidarity for someone who is ill and it just happens to be framed in a religious way. Perhaps these incidents are fulfilling valuable social functions completely outside of whether or not the prayers of those involved are directly affecting anything. It's important to feel connected to and supported by a group, which is what I get out of anyone offering to pray for me or my family.