Feb. 27th, 2021

stormdog: a woman with light skin and long brown hair that cascades over one shoulder. On her other side, she is holding a large plush shark against herself. She has pink fingernails and pink cat eye glasses (Default)
Something I wrote in a class forum as we go through a week focusing on ethics.
-------
On the ALA's professional ethics page that was in the readings for this week, the authors quote the 7th edition of the Intellectual Freedom Manual in part as follows:

"Intellectual freedom can exist only where two essential conditions are met: first, that all individuals have the right to hold any belief on any subject and to convey their ideas in any form they deem appropriate..."

This statement has been bothering me for a while now and I want to know if other folks are similarly troubled.

The ALA seems to be saying that intellectual freedom means I can believe whatever I want to believe, and I can express that belief in whatever way is appropriate to me. I agree with the first part of that. And even if I didn't, it wouldn't matter. I can't make anyone think or stop thinking something. But I don't know how that second part should be applied to the context of a library or similar. Patrons should *not* be able to express their beliefs in whatever way they feel is appropriate or we'll have an environment that encourages and protects hate speech. I don't think it is possible to create an environment that is welcoming to everyone, because the very presence of some groups is going to make other groups feel unwelcome.

The ethics question from the expanded list this week regarding white supremacists reserving library space is, of course, an example of this. Twenty years ago, I probably would have argued for their right to use the space just like any other group. At this point in my life and in history, as racists and bigots feel emboldened and normalized by a social atmosphere in which people are unwilling to call these kinds of cancerous growths on the body of culture what they are, I would not argue for that right. I would argue against it. I think the ALA should too.

Profile

stormdog: a woman with light skin and long brown hair that cascades over one shoulder. On her other side, she is holding a large plush shark against herself. She has pink fingernails and pink cat eye glasses (Default)
MeghanIsMe

January 2025

S M T W T F S
   1234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
262728293031 

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Jun. 12th, 2025 03:14 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios